ROUND 1: EXRER vs. iAndy [EXRER Won]

[XTO --]

Competitors: EXRER vs. iAndy

Objective: Best free-style editing.
Stunt: http://www.4shared.com/rar/279YCYyw/EXRER_vs_iAndy.html
(Stunt by XtremeOmega)


Deadline: 3 days from now (+2 days extension)


Note: Objectives regarding looks and color corrections, will be rated according to this:

• Best look: Look>Color Correction>Editing
• Best Color Correction: Color Correction>Look>Editing

[ExRer]

Not much understand this: 

Note: Objectives regarding looks and color corrections, will be rated according to this:

• Best look: Look>Color Correction>Editing
• Best Color Correction: Color Correction>Look>Editing

  (btw good luck iAndy)

[iAndy]

Yea' I don't understand it either...
Freestyle means I got free-hand on this one?

Anyway, good luck to you to Exrer.

Edit: I request a two day extension of the deadline mainly because I'm not home during this weekend (nor am I sober). If you can make it happen it will be great.

[Ltab-]

I suppose you are able to get focused in 1 type of editing or effects or whatever. Or all of them.

[XTO --]

Best free-style means that you can use anything, with any song and do whatever you want. We'll rate it in the best editing overall.


Also, as said in the other topic, if your oponent agrees, then yes, you'll get an extension

[ExRer]

you got it 

e: Can i post entry and then to deadline another entry ? (backup)

[XTO --]

You can change your entry before he posts his. After he post his, you cannot

[ExRer]

You can change your entry before he posts his. After he post his, you cannot

Thanks

e: so this is maybe not last entry...maybe
GTAS ET 2012 | [ExRer] vs. iAndy

[iAndy]

Here's my entry after all. Good luck mate!

GTAStunting - Editing Tournament 2012 - [iAndy] vs. Exrer

[ExRer]

voting time . good luck iAndy 

[Kukiel]

That's a pretty tough one.
EXRER: I didn't like the little intro you made. It looked bad. But then when song kicked off you did really well. I liked energy of the video and cc that went along song. Effects were nice and well placed and it overall looked really nice.
iAndy: Though your intro was nice, it was completely out of context. You should have made some camera works in place the stunt was done in. And I recommend not using those transitions since they're pretty ugly. Then it got better. I liked the edit but it was nothing really special.

I'll vote for EXRER since I really enjoyed the speed of his entry.

[Ltab-]

Kukiel took the words from my mouth

Voting for EXRER aswell

[WaRoW]

Kukiel said everything.
My vote goes to EXRER.

[XTO --]

I was going to vote for iAndy, but then, after reading Kukiel's full review, I rewatched EXRER (I didn't like it at first) and I must say that I agree with his statements.

iAndy had a killer intro, except it didn't have anything to do with the video itself, but his 'main' edit wasn't as good as EXRER.

Vote goes to EXRER

[iAndy]

I see how it is. Working freestyle means to have your own vision of everything. I don't see how you could possible assume that in my vision, the video does not fit. You guys totally stepped over those objectives regarding the looks of the video but I can handle it. Neither of you judges (expect for WaRoW) have any touches with imagination. You just go with the wind, and don't step out of the box.

This situations make me believe that art is forgotten.

Good luck with the rest of your challenges EXRER (you will need it when you have judges who can't use their own words and just follow a straight idea).

To the rest, see you in hell .