Round 3 - VTX vs. MtS [VTX wins 4-3]

[PtRvY]

I must say that I had a very tough time thinking about it.

Pros:

VTX - Really nice way to use the portable staircase, and the precision just adds up.
MtS - Obviously a cool idea, also you used a immobile staircase which gives you a small advantage.

Cons:

VTX - The staircase was placed in a position where it might look kinda tricky to place the baggage handler (not saying it's impossible, just spoils the look for me).
MtS - You completely went out of the two wheel-ride before you hit the ramp, which makes it almost not a part of the stunt for me. Also the landing wasn't executed properly even if you managed to turn around.

Tough, tough call. I'm gonna vote for VTX.

[MeetMyMeat]

Mts receieves my vote for thinking out-of-the-box-and-into-the-dimension-of-endless-pumpkin-pie.

and because VTX's entry was incredibly bad

[Asaaj]

Voting for VTX because of the clean execution and the portable staircase involvement :3

[Simon]

"Challenge: Best stunt where you use the portable staircase found at the airports. (Simon)"

So VTX gets my vote, because MtS's entry is invalid in my eyes.

[GDL]

My vote goes to VTX but only because MtS didn't complete the objective imo.

[MtS]

.

[VTX]

Thanks MtS! 

[Franco]

"Challenge: Best stunt where you use the portable staircase found at the airports. (Simon)"

So VTX gets my vote, because MtS's entry is invalid in my eyes.

My vote goes to VTX but only because MtS didn't complete the objective imo.

Don't know if MtS asked if it was allowed to use those stairs, if any judge told him it was, your votes are invalid... If he didn't then it's all okay 

[MeetMyMeat]

"Challenge: Best stunt where you use the portable staircase found at the airports. (Simon)"

So VTX gets my vote, because MtS's entry is invalid in my eyes.

I guess we have one more fucked up situation on our hands. The immobile staircases at the airports are portable in real life, and I would've considered them to be fitting this objective as well. Seriously, judges, be more fucking specific and elaborate or back your challenges up with pics.

Really disappointed.

[PtRvY]

Those immobile staircases indeed would be portable in real life too.

I'd like you two guys to vote again if this changes your decision.

[GDL]

Don't get me wrong, I think MtS' stunt was better. But, I think PtRvY clearly stated what is meant to be a 'portable staircase' by posting a picture of one. I wouldn't mind if MtS asked if he can use the one that he used, but he didn't (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong here).

[PtRvY]

Don't get me wrong, I think MtS' stunt was better. But, I think PtRvY clearly stated what is meant to be a 'portable staircase' by posting a picture of one. I wouldn't mind if MtS asked if he can use the one that he used, but he didn't (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong here).

In that case your vote is changed to MtS because you didn't read my entire post correctly.

There, I found one at the SF airport
http://noob.hu/2011/06/10/paint.png

It's also towable (you can attach it to a baggage handler as in this pic) so you can put it wherever you want

And of course you can also use the ones at the LS airport too.

I posted a picture of that one because MtS said he couldn't find any at SF. So I showed a pic of one at SF ^^

[Simon]

"Challenge: Best stunt where you use the portable staircase found at the airports. (Simon)"

So VTX gets my vote, because MtS's entry is invalid in my eyes.

I guess we have one more fucked up situation on our hands. The immobile staircases at the airports are portable in real life, and I would've considered them to be fitting this objective as well. Seriously, judges, be more fucking specific and elaborate or back your challenges up with pics.

Really disappointed.

Yeah and stunting is doable in real life? NO so then every entry should be invalid? Seriously we are doing this in a game. And we go by the game, not real life.

Really disappointed.

[Turtle Dick]

Voting for MtS as he had the better stunt. I'm not gonna touch the ambiguous objective discussion

[FELIX]

It's a shame I have to do this. Even tho I hate kicking MtS from the tournament... I liked VTX stunt more. He completed the (for me) obvious Challenge + his stunt looked better IN MY OPINION.

So I will vote for VTX.