[BT] Extravaganza!

[Asaaj]

Hated petar's and senti's part the music and the flashes in petars part were absolute horror. Senti had a nice editing but the song WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT 

[JustCaus3]

nothing like nucleus but it surely was really good vid imo, senti owned but the song was ok for the sound but the singing was awful.. petar was also cool so was beat and dundee  no comments on the stunts but that wasn't the point i guess.. Intro was really cool also.. 7/10

[TrYp]

I expected so much more stunting wise I only liked Streem's LS watergap, Sylar's stunt near the SF church and Rusch's stuff. Editing wise it was mindblowing.

[Damster 2]

ehm when i sent the stunts none of them was old

and i liked the flashes in petars part

[MaRo]

awesome

[Zenaku]

Intro
It was pretty cool, i first thought it was done by Warow, then i checked and i understood why the signs at the beginning were like in Lazarus. 

BeaT
Pretty nice part, some effects were nicely done and fited well to te song. That Rage effect was used in Sentit' best of and was better imo  but if it's half year old, i understand and yeah your actual edits are better. I found this part a little bit boring. 

Dundee
Fucking awesome part, it was my favorite one. Those masking effects were epic dude and you make them perfectly synced to the song. You did a really great job and you look have worked hard on it. (y)

PtRvY
On the first song, i was quite suprised because i saw a clean edit. It was nice but i expected more from you.
On the second song (i lost it ), it was colorful and powerful but a little bit random imo. I know it's hard to find the effects who fit the best 

SentitneS
Beginning of the song was kinda horrible, too hard. The editing was nice, i liked most of the effects.

OVERALL!
I have to admit i'm quite disappointed. By wacthing the trailer,i thought i would find something extra epic, but it wasn't
I can't judge the stunts because i didn't even take a look on them and idc
Dundee stoud out imo.It's still a good collab

[oNdeR]

Pretty awesome I loved your edits but especially I like in this order, PtRvY, Dundee, Beat, SentineS. At 6:10 Damster's stunt was very impressive just like that the other guys very good job in overall to everyone. 9/10...

[KasT]

First of all,i didn't like how the intro started,mostly because i didn't like the font used for "beyondtomorrow".Also,the first cam angle was really bad and that text was way too big considering the cam angle was that close.But appart from that it was really exciting and stylish.The ending was brilliant,i really loved it.

Beat's part:
Bad choice of opener,it didn't really fit well and that second angle was not needed at all.Not to mention that the "transition" between those 2 angles was ugly.The effects were pretty much the same all the time : only flashes and red ray effects.And why don't you show the grinds till the end?You better find a way to show them completly cuz those cuts are really annoying tbh.The only good thing about this part is the cc,which was really awesome,but overall,i can say i am a bit dissapointed.I expected much more from you.(even if it's a 6 months old work).
About the stunts,i didn't like any of the stunts except GDL's freeway double grind.The others were either old,either lame or bad.
I'd rate it 6/10.

Dundee's part
Idk what's wrong with your aspect ratio but it's really annoying for me atleast lol.The editing overall was really good,but obviously not your best one.It seemed rushed and it lacked your awesome creative ideas your other edits have.Also,the song was fucking horrible,sorry to say.I just hate that type of music.But appart from the song,i really enjoyed the editing.
The stunts..Again,nothing special.Most of them were old or lame and Delfy modded.I liked Streem's stuff only.
I'd rate it 8/10.

PtRvY's Part
Well,this is the part i enjoyed almost as much as Sentitnes' part.Mostly because of the track choice.It was really awesome.The first part of it was alright but the second one,after it skips from day to night..DAAMN,it was freaking amazing.It's the part i really enjoyed the most,brilliant.I loved how the song changedYour best editing so far imo.Keep it up this way.About the stunts,i liked Darkstar's and Sylar's stunt(if not modded),that's all.
I'd give a 9/10.

Sentitnes' Part
The best part from the video.Solid editing consisting in meticulous details which gave everything alot of dynamism.You obviously know what fits the best to every beat/sequence of the song.It was a really fantastic editing.Oh and that "WTFISTHIS D:" scene was fucking awesome lol.I didn't like any of the stunts here and the finisher was modded.
I'd rate this editing with a 10/10,it really deserves it.

Overall: Even if it's an editing collab,it doesn't mean you have to accept every shitty stunt.Next time try to accept only decent(atleast) and not modded stunts.It will be better.And not that this video was bad,but i enjoyed Nucleus alot more,as the others mentioned before.

[Wozzie]

BeaT's part so fucking awesome 

[ERROR]

2nd part 1:12, magic? O.o

[PtRvY]

Thanks everyone, KasT especially - that review was really good and kinda reflects my thoughts on the video too.

I guess that our goal wasn't really to beat nucleus. I always wanted to take part in a video like this (I was supposed to be a editor in nucleus but one of the guys said no in the last moment), since I think it's a unique experience, and also I had a great time organizing this with my crewmates. Fine, nucleus might not have been beaten, but we've had hella fun - though, I have to admit, I wouldn't want to make something like this again, big videos like this ALWAYS fuck up somehow/somewhere.

Oh and Martin - I've downloaded the .mkv of your part and played it maximum sound. Everyone in a 1km radius shat their pants.

[Tom]

Ok here is my review of the editing, not the stunts.

Beats Part- This was by far my favorite part, the CC was amazing and the effects were great. The flashes were perfectly synced and the camera angles were different, (instead of the same old boring angles).

Overall Rating:9.5/10

Dundee's Part:I lalso loved this part, but the biggest problem with it was the resolution, that widescreen or whatever didnt look good, and it almost completely ruined that part. But still, the editing was very good, the masking ideas ere excellent, and the effects were not overused, good job.

Overall Rating:7/10

PtRvY's Part- This part was my second favorite of the entire video. Not far behind Beat's. The ideas and effects you used were simply amazing, and the purpose of this video was to focus on the editing (hence, it being an editing crew video), and boooy did you edit    This was definetally an overedit, and im not saying that in a bad way.

Overall Rating:9/10

SentineS's Part: Sorry, but this was the worst part of the video in my opinion. It might have been better if the song was different. But hey, we all have a different taste in music  The effects and CC were solid though, so i cant completely diss this part.

Overall Rating:6/10

Overall decent video guys, the stunts were horrible ( besides Streems stunts ).

Overall Video Rating: 7/10

 

[ChriStunter]

Well not going to say anything about the stunts because I know this collab is all about the editing of you guys.
Intro was fucking good, best part of the video in my opinion, it looked very professional and well made.
Well as MMM said, the nametags are the most shitty nametags I have ever seen. The Extravaganza font was way too big and I couldn't even notice
who made each stunts because of the little font the stunters had compared to the giant Extravaganza one.
I'm not a big fan of your editing Beat but I have to admit I enjoyed it this time, maybe because the song used, don't know.
Didn't like the cam angles though and that color correction you have used too much now.
This was the worst part in my opinion, Color correction was crap and the cam angles weren't very good either. The effects were very synced but I don't like these kind of editings.
Petar, I have to admit you amazed me this time. It started just awesome, very fitting effects and just the necessary ones, some very good angles but then you just made it all crap, why the fuck did you overedit it when it was going so good?
Anyway your part was better than the previous ones so congratz.
This was the best part for sure, everything was perfect, CC, cam angles,etc. I'll download the mkv of your version dude, the effects were so synched and well done, fucking awesome. Only things I don't like about your videos are the songs you use.

[Sear]

Sadly the bad stunts ruined it, obviously theres is no chance for good stunts only for such a long video, but i couldnt even focus on the editing, which was really good.

GJ editors

[Jubito]

Really liked it.
To be honest, even if I know shit about editing, all of you did a good job and I liked all of the edits.