Author Topic: ESH - Exotherm  (Read 6187 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline miLKy

  • Posts: 369
  • ESH <3
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #30 on: June 16, 2010, 10:47:41 AM »
Erasus opener was weird but maybe clean. Best vid of the year so far imo, simply outstanding.
Nauthiluz upload your version, I'm downloading one version but I don't know if it's yours.

Nauthiluz' version: http://www.megaupload.com/?d=PXODPCRH
Dundee's version: http://www.multiupload.com/W0CELH9EKH

Offline PtRvY

  • WH Crew
  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 4153
  • Wasteland Hero / BT Member
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #31 on: June 16, 2010, 11:30:46 AM »
Full review of exothermic reactions by PetarHD

First of all, late apology guys, i was supposed to do a script for nauthiluz' part but since i had one of the hardest periods in school these days I had really little time for anything. Once again I'm sorry.

Editing: Watched both versions. In short: Nauthiluz version gave a nice feeling with a few feelingkiller effects though, while Dundee's version was the best possible editing i could imagine on Self vs. Self. One of my all-time favourites. Dundee, stay creative in editing, keep coming up with new ideas while always spicing it up with the previous stuff that worked. Maybe not all of the new ideas will always work, but with the recent invasion of warow-copiers claiming to be 'creative', you're one of the few editors that I find really creative. 9.5/10

2:27-2:32: best moment of the video. Simply shows how amazing things you can make by combining two already tried-out ideas. Also the first playerpuncher had my helmet txd, almost thought it was me  :lol:

Stunts:
0:35-0:48 Eraser: Honestly, I was never THAT impressed with ESH videos before (stunt-wise). So I didn't expect anything too special for a opener. However, wow, that was one simply stunning dropbump, awesome work on it, kinda sucked me in to watch the rest of the video with my eyes wide open. 9.5/10
0:48-0:59 [miLKy_wAy]: Doesn't look so hard for a sandking bump but pretty damn neat, also i somehow love all stunts landed to that building. 8/10
0:59-1:19 Nauthiluz: Simply amazing, still remember it from your xsa audi, gz on finding yet another way to land this crane. 9/10
1:19-1:37 Eraser: I don't find those boxes that interesting. The execution is nice tho. 8/10
1:37-1:54 Dundee: Fucking awesome, shame that you were 'hanging' there for quite a while, but nvm nvm, your stunts are approaching the level of your editing. 9/10
1:54-2:02 Siet: Not bad, but it doesnt seem hard at all, not good for the eye either, at least from that cam angle. 7.5/10
2:02-2:16 Nauthiluz: Awesome to finally see bluedagger's chall landed, I've tried it myself so i know what a bitch it was. You're a really good booster. 9.5/10
2:16-2:26 Nick: Seems like a short airtime and a short wallride ... something lower than what I'd expect from you, but then again I havent seen you stunting with a infy much. 7/10
2:33-2:44 Savatage: Pretty cool, gj landing this stunt to the far building. 9/10
2:44-2:53 Willi: Looks like a neat little cute spot, but the short grind kinda kills it. 8/10
2:53-3:16 Nauthiluz: Another stunt from teh xsa audi, wasn't as impressive as others (since the precision space isnt that hard to land on), but still pretty nice. 8.5/10
3:16-3:27 Eraser: Stunt of the video. After the bump i thought 'wtf, he's going nowhere', when you got on the grind it was like 'meh, will probably be another short grind which isnt really a grind'... but when I seen you do it completely, man, my jaw hit the floor. Mad props. 10/10
3:27-3:38 Mezaka: It's a rightside boost which makes it good for me, also gj at finding another way of landing the crane. 9/10
3:38-4:00 Nauthiluz: You showed me this some time ago, I was pretty impressed that you were able to land my stunt to higher precision. However, not the suitable finisher for this video imo. Still a pretty rock-ish stunt. 9.5/10

Outro: Music already used by Dogger in outro of Conspiracy II, he gave it a better feeling. But hey, who the hell is watching outros anyway? It doesn't decrease the vids value at all, after all the effort you put in the main. 7/10

Overall: The best ESH video, and the fact it has a theme / restriction which surely didnt fit every member the same, just steps it even more up in my opinion. GJ, you made something which totally impressed me and I'm looking forward to your next one.

9/10

Offline Sava

  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 1527
  • me tbh
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #32 on: June 16, 2010, 11:35:33 AM »
Thanks for that big review Petar and the others  :P

Offline miLKy

  • Posts: 369
  • ESH <3
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #33 on: June 16, 2010, 11:44:11 AM »
Full review of exothermic reactions by PetarHD

First of all, late apology guys, i was supposed to do a script for nauthiluz' part but since i had one of the hardest periods in school these days I had really little time for anything. Once again I'm sorry.

Editing: Watched both versions. In short: Nauthiluz version gave a nice feeling with a few feelingkiller effects though, while Dundee's version was the best possible editing i could imagine on Self vs. Self. One of my all-time favourites. Dundee, stay creative in editing, keep coming up with new ideas while always spicing it up with the previous stuff that worked. Maybe not all of the new ideas will always work, but with the recent invasion of warow-copiers claiming to be 'creative', you're one of the few editors that I find really creative. 9.5/10


2:27-2:32: best moment of the video. Simply shows how amazing things you can make by combining two already tried-out ideas. Also the first playerpuncher had my helmet txd, almost thought it was me  :lol:

Stunts:
0:35-0:48 Eraser: Honestly, I was never THAT impressed with ESH videos before (stunt-wise). So I didn't expect anything too special for a opener. However, wow, that was one simply stunning dropbump, awesome work on it, kinda sucked me in to watch the rest of the video with my eyes wide open. 9.5/10
0:48-0:59 [miLKy_wAy]: Doesn't look so hard for a sandking bump but pretty damn neat, also i somehow love all stunts landed to that building. 8/10
0:59-1:19 Nauthiluz: Simply amazing, still remember it from your xsa audi, gz on finding yet another way to land this crane. 9/10
1:19-1:37 Eraser: I don't find those boxes that interesting. The execution is nice tho. 8/10
1:37-1:54 Dundee: Fucking awesome, shame that you were 'hanging' there for quite a while, but nvm nvm, your stunts are approaching the level of your editing. 9/10
1:54-2:02 Siet: Not bad, but it doesnt seem hard at all, not good for the eye either, at least from that cam angle. 7.5/10
2:02-2:16 Nauthiluz: Awesome to finally see bluedagger's chall landed, I've tried it myself so i know what a bitch it was. You're a really good booster. 9.5/10
2:16-2:26 Nick: Seems like a short airtime and a short wallride ... something lower than what I'd expect from you, but then again I havent seen you stunting with a infy much. 7/10
2:33-2:44 Savatage: Pretty cool, gj landing this stunt to the far building. 9/10
2:44-2:53 Willi: Looks like a neat little cute spot, but the short grind kinda kills it. 8/10
2:53-3:16 Nauthiluz: Another stunt from teh xsa audi, wasn't as impressive as others (since the precision space isnt that hard to land on), but still pretty nice. 8.5/10
3:16-3:27 Eraser: Stunt of the video. After the bump i thought 'wtf, he's going nowhere', when you got on the grind it was like 'meh, will probably be another short grind which isnt really a grind'... but when I seen you do it completely, man, my jaw hit the floor. Mad props. 10/10
3:27-3:38 Mezaka: It's a rightside boost which makes it good for me, also gj at finding another way of landing the crane. 9/10
3:38-4:00 Nauthiluz: You showed me this some time ago, I was pretty impressed that you were able to land my stunt to higher precision. However, not the suitable finisher for this video imo. Still a pretty rock-ish stunt. 9.5/10

Outro: Music already used by Dogger in outro of Conspiracy II, he gave it a better feeling. But hey, who the hell is watching outros anyway? It doesn't decrease the vids value at all, after all the effort you put in the main. 7/10

Overall: The best ESH video, and the fact it has a theme / restriction which surely didnt fit every member the same, just steps it even more up in my opinion. GJ, you made something which totally impressed me and I'm looking forward to your next one.

9/10

:wub:

Offline Plani

  • --
  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 4387
  • Since 2008
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #34 on: June 16, 2010, 11:47:54 AM »
Cool vid.Some stunts were awesome like Nauthiluz' and Eraser's stuff , but the rest wasnt so impressive and some were boring too.Editing (Nauthiluz version) was great and relaxing.

Offline Doubt

  • Posts: 580
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #35 on: June 16, 2010, 11:49:01 AM »
awesome video guys.i liked every stunt..the eraser`s grind fucking pwned like almost every stunt from this vid :a-cheer:

Offline EraserGTA

  • Posts: 3
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #36 on: June 16, 2010, 01:52:54 PM »
thank you very much for the great feedbacks.  :happy:

Offline Franco

  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 587
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #37 on: June 16, 2010, 03:28:44 PM »
Holly shit!

Eraser pulled off one of the greatest Car Grinds ever... It was just flawless man, great bump and insane precision on landing perfectly on the grind and holding up for a looooooong and sweet grind. One of the best stunts this year man, great job on it.

Everyone was nice too. Cabbies were sexy.


About editing I gotta disagree with Petar on this one. This, for me, was a horrible way to ruin such an awesome song man...
I have to admit that synchronism was at the highest level, so was the variation and inovation on the FX'ing. But every one of them, or most of the effects were freaking ugly and rough, no smoothness in any way. Maybe that was the theme Dundee chose, but imo it is not Eye Pleasent... Collors are too bad looking for this video, only in some very interesting parts you managed to create great collors with the song mood.
I'm not saying it was a bad editing, cause it was awesome and waaaaaay above average. But it is far from being a perfect fit for this awesome Track...

Will watch Nauthiluz version later

Offline PtRvY

  • WH Crew
  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 4153
  • Wasteland Hero / BT Member
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #38 on: June 16, 2010, 03:36:50 PM »
Holly shit!

Eraser pulled off one of the greatest Car Grinds ever... It was just flawless man, great bump and insane precision on landing perfectly on the grind and holding up for a looooooong and sweet grind. One of the best stunts this year man, great job on it.

Everyone was nice too. Cabbies were sexy.


About editing I gotta disagree with Petar on this one. This, for me, was a horrible way to ruin such an awesome song man...
I have to admit that synchronism was at the highest level, so was the variation and inovation on the FX'ing. But every one of them, or most of the effects were freaking ugly and rough, no smoothness in any way. Maybe that was the theme Dundee chose, but imo it is not Eye Pleasent... Collors are too bad looking for this video, only in some very interesting parts you managed to create great collors with the song mood.
I'm not saying it was a bad editing, cause it was awesome and waaaaaay above average. But it is far from being a perfect fit for this awesome Track...

Will watch Nauthiluz version later

two things

he couldnt have 'ruined' the song since its old already
and, opinionz. (for example, in my opinion you watched too many smooth videos so you think almost nothing is smooth  :ajaja: )

no wait, third thing. if you think this song can be edited to better, go on and edit a video with it. I wouldn't mind seeing what you could come up with  :euro: (no sarcasm or anything intended there)
« Last Edit: June 16, 2010, 03:39:58 PM by PtRvY »

Offline MtS

  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 2006
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #39 on: June 16, 2010, 03:58:05 PM »
.
« Last Edit: April 05, 2017, 10:37:02 PM by mateus »

Offline Franco

  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 587
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #40 on: June 16, 2010, 04:19:12 PM »
and, opinionz. (for example, in my opinion you watched too many smooth videos so you think almost nothing is smooth  :ajaja: )

Hahaha, I think you might be right on that  :lol:

no wait, third thing. if you think this song can be edited to better, go on and edit a video with it. I wouldn't mind seeing what you could come up with  :euro: (no sarcasm or anything intended there)

Quite an interesting idea... Always wanted to edit to a hardcore soundtrack, but I'm too weak on overediting  :(

Offline Rusch69

  • Senior Member
  • Posts: 2990
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #41 on: June 20, 2010, 05:31:02 AM »
Editing: Overall a really great video imo. The only minus points probably were the fucked up audio quality and the color changes. CC was a bit too colorless, but kinda interesting though. Song is really great, lil shame you cutted off the best part. I pretty much liked the flashes and those cuts which leave out some frames. Masking was really accurate and clean. Rather that then chroma keyed stuff which mostly got shitty quality. Incoming camera on Sava's bump and the scene with those CJs were good. Overall imo it is one of the best edited videos this year so far. Well nothing will own Recred I think though lol.


Stunts:
0:35-0:48 Eraser: Great bump. Hopefully it is unmodded. Really grea that you even landed it's ledge.
0:48-0:59 [miLKy_wAy]: Not really that appealing, seen something better there :man:, still great for a Sandking one.
0:59-1:19 Nauthiluz: Great idea. Shame you lay on the side, but okay.
1:19-1:37 Eraser: Not really a precision, but I like the way you got it. Thumbs up for drop bumps.
1:37-1:54 Dundee: Been trying it on PSA many times after the LV respawn lol. Fun to try and good looking imo.
1:54-2:02 Siet: Hmm kinda interesting to bump in such a side-wheelie. Doesn't look that hard/good somehow.
2:02-2:16 Nauthiluz: Nice to see that landed.
2:16-2:26 Nick: I think that is old by Kert.
2:33-2:44 Savatage: Kinda abvious it'd get landed that way. My personal favourite is still Aero opener.
2:44-2:53 Willi: Car grinds are way too rare! I don't really like this Bullet leaping though + the grind looked kinda sloppy. Still good cuz its a car grind lol.
2:53-3:16 Nauthiluz: Another awesome precision. Great idea which is nicely executed.
3:16-3:27 Eraser: Probably stunt of the video. Off from the camera angle your height looked really high. Clean flip and smooth grind. Really great if done without any changes.
3:27-3:38 Mezaka: Tbh cranes kinda get lame, there are many other sweet precisions. Also I don't get why you dropped off the roof, wouldn't it work to just start straighty from down there? Anyway, great spin onto it.
3:38-4:00 Nauthiluz: Also nice, though I expected the top getting landed. I know that'd be easier, but somehow would've been more appealing imo. Also stunt with other vehicles dude D:

Outro: Simple and clean. Nothing special to mention.

Offline __JREN

  • Posts: 2783
  • Beyond Tomorrow
    • View Profile
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #42 on: January 04, 2011, 03:56:52 PM »
how could I miss this video?
that editing + that music = dundeeeee <3

btw enjoyed nauthis version too

Offline Syny

  • Posts: 3145
  • People need to learn and enjoy solitude
    • View Profile
    • http://www.youtube.com/user/SrSyny
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #43 on: January 04, 2011, 04:36:27 PM »
Awesome video, the Dundee and Nauthiluz versions are really good
I love Eraser and Nauthiluz stuff   :a-cheer:


Offline White

  • Redux
  • Veteran Member
  • Posts: 1413
    • View Profile
    • WhiteXful
Re: ESH - Exotherm
« Reply #44 on: January 05, 2011, 06:58:05 AM »
how could I miss this video?
that editing + that music = dundeeeee <3

btw enjoyed nauthis version too
The Date :(
It's too late :sleep:

 

SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2024, SimplePortal