ROUND 1: Kacknase vs. Tracker [Kacknase Won]

[XTO --]

Competitors: Kacknase vs. Tracker

Objective: Best edit to a rock song
Stunt: http://www.4shared.com/rar/-hkFiWtX/Kack_vs_Tracker.html
(Stunt by Rainbow)


Deadline: 3 days from now


Note: Objectives regarding looks and color corrections, will be rated according to this:

• Best look: Look>Color Correction>Editing
• Best Color Correction: Color Correction>Look>Editing

[Mati]

[VCET] Kacknase vs. Tracker, Tracker's enry.

Good Luck.

[D.JacK]

really enjoyable man

[Kacknase]

GTASET - Round 1 - Kacknase vs. Tracker

[Ltab-]

Tracker: Good editing man, transitions were cool and cam angles too, and the CC was stylish also. The song made the ambient, was really a good one

Kacknase: Amazing atmosphere, the time and CC both were like sticked to the song. It was simple but effective, it's not very common to see that in nowadays editings.

2 great entrys, but I will choose Kacknase's one

[WaRoW]

Tracker: That was nice, but i didn't like the song and the nametag's place.
Kacknase: What a nice song and an amazing CC. Loved these fixed camera at the beginning.

My vote goes to Kacknase

[Kukiel]

That was very solid match. Both entries were pretty great. I really enjoyed Tracker's version but at the same time Kacknase's one was damn awesome. It's a shame you had to stumble upon such an oponent, Tracker.
Also lack of Nickleback in Kacknase's version was really nice.

My vote goes to Kacknase, for awesome editing.

[Rainbow]

^you failed with the Kacknase picture there  Or was that intentional?

And @ Tracker: Was that really 30fps?

[Christian]

I'll just say this - the only guy can beat Kacknase in rock editing challenge is Herr-Dav'. Kacknase's entry was amazing, really loved that intro on VRock and the whole combination. Tracker's entry was also close enough but Kacknase killed it for me. Vote to Kacknase.

[Kukiel]

^you failed with the Kacknase picture there  Or was that intentional?

And @ Tracker: Was that really 30fps?

I inserted [img] instead of [ b].

[XTO --]

I'm voting for Tracker because his intro was perfectly fitting to the song, and the masking under it was really good-looking.

For a full review PM