ROUND 1: Dundee vs. Electric [Dundee Won]

[XTO --]

Competitors: Dundee vs. Electric

Objective: Best atmosphere using a Black and White CC with any song
Stunt: http://www.4shared.com/rar/k1Zm6t_T/Dundee_vs_Electric.html
(Stunt by Kukiel)


Deadline: 3 days from now


Note: Objectives regarding looks and color corrections, will be rated according to this:

• Best look: Look>Color Correction>Editing
• Best Color Correction: Color Correction>Look>Editing

[electric]

fml  i hate black & white cc´s    well i aint gonna bitch about it  ... well gl dundee   ima still try my best !!!!

[Dundee]

gl electric 

[electric]

gtas et round 1 against dundee [electrics entry] 

[Dundee]

ET 2012 - Round 1 Dundee vs. Electric


GL again dude

[Ltab-]

electric: Good CC you've made, looked nice. Plus the black border and the darkness touch you used was great And the song fitted perfectly to the atmosphere..

Dundee: Was a cool CC, looked normal but stylish. Nevertheless best was atmosphere, looked chill and nice, specially the way you cut the clip, plus the red flash looked weird but at the same time was original, something unusual that it's not always seen on an editing. Oh and nice rainbow and dust effect.


Vote goes to Dundee

[GDL]

Electric's CC was cool but his pan/crops and pinch/punch made his entry worse.

Dundee's was great, I loved the cuts matching to the glitchy song and the use of the flares was just amazing 

Vote for Dundee.

[Christian]

Both of the entries were top notch, but top notch in a different way...
While electric's entry was calm and nice and well done, Dundee's was really... well atmosphereless for me, or I atleast thats how I feel it.
You both fulfilled the objective but I have to choose between good editing and good atmosphere. I'll go with electric here.

[Kukiel]

To be perfectly honest neither of entries had the atmosphere. I mean both editing were pretty cool but I think you could use some better songs for the challenge, especially Dundee.
In that case I'll have to vote judging by the editing it self and it's no surprise that Dundee's version was better. You're great editor, man, but please choose songs more wisely.

[WaRoW]

Electric: It isn't a black and white i guess, but i will accept it. The Edit wasn't special but it was cool.
Dundee: Loved that playing with Freeway's light and the song.

My vote goes to Dundee.

[XTO --]

Dundee's idea of mixing Colorful flares with the B&W CC made it for me. Even if I disliked some aspects of your video, as angles and that rainbow-like thing, it was still better than Electrics.

Vote goes to Dundee.

Pm for full reviews