GTAStunting
GTA Series => Grand Theft Auto - San Andreas => SA Un-Modded Video Releases => Topic started by: Phamus on November 29, 2011, 04:56:28 PM
-
Hello Guys!
The long awaited Magic, is finally here, and I'm proud of the outcome.
I'd like to thank the WhiteLabel members for the motivation, and also the stunters for the collaboration
GTAStunting & WorldOfStunt | MAGIC (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaR6ZUbuxQM#ws)
Organizer:
Phamus
Editors (in order):
-eXe
-Static
-Furious
-D.Jack
-Phamus
Stunters:
-Flippa
-Juuretis
-Nka19
-Stunta4life
-BallBuzZ
-DaVe
-Static
-Syny
-Pisces
-Electric
-Nubie
-Mike ( MAK )
-PK
-eXe
Few notes:
We did not, in any way, think to compete with the video of SKRILLEX in terms of enternainment, neither video aspects.
To review on Furious' part, it's his first over-edit experience which you should be more aware of.
And lastly, to clarify, this is an overedit collab. But again, I appreciate your feedback, it gives us a lesson into improving.
Download link soon.
Thank you for your time.
-
FIRST? YEA ;D
Later comments :wub:,and you will upload the downloader,dude?
-
The Download link - 3 hours left :(
-
Sorry, but this was awful! The CCs were complete shit, the effects were flashy and ugly and there were too many of them, the camera angels were all really bad, the banners were annoying and the resolution of some parts were very off. Also nearly all stunts were shit, old or already used in other collabs.
Sorry if this is harsh but, I really hope this is not the future of SA editing, please go back to using those superdark CCs so we can't see the fail as clearly. :3
-
Thanks for your feedback and again, that's just someone's point of view which in any way does not contradict on my overall feelings on this video.
To clarify, this is a collab targeted to get two communities together, and I did not in any way mention that I needed new stunts when I crated the topic.
Super dark CC's? Give me an example. And the joke did not project as good as it should. Abhorrent.
And what banners are you talking about? Would love to taste your art of being specific better, instead of spilling out labourious things :ajaja:
-
AAAAAAAAAAAAArghGH F1RSTTT
e/ It was cool, better than expected actually, sometimes editing was kinda dull or without sense at all :lol: so here a little review about editing.
eXe
Decent editing, not so bad but you had some weird effects imo. Sometimes the backward motion and those cuts were kinda annoying, but liked a lot those tv simulators coulours, also the pancrop work was well done ;) Also I see you avoid camfucks :lol:
Static
DAMN this was fucking awesome, best part imo. CC was damn cool as always, angles were awesome, and the effects were really fitting to the song. Specially because it was Skrillex remix :wub: Effects were fucking awesome, the pancrop was, damn I have no words. I describe everything with the editing on the fisrt stunt. The earthquake effect was nice too, also the way that you made the transitions at nametags were nice to watch. Transitions were awesome too. My only dislike was that sometimes the cam was too close to the vehicle, imo that's not really nice but fuck it :D
Furious
Well it was kinda disappointing since I've seen your last project, but overall was nice, effects were kinda weird but the pancrop it's cool. Like in Syny's stunt, it gave a good atmosphere :P Also the scratches effects was cool :P
DJK
As always awesome cam angles/earthquake/pancrop work! Damn Can't describe them, they were really cool :P These colours were killers, gave a good atmosphere to the vid, dislike the soundtrack but nice overall, Liked a lot the editing on that finisher, awesome angles :P
Phamus
Funny way of putting nametags! :P Liked angles, fitting to the effects that you've made. Loved the way that you've used the slow motion and the blur motion effect. The second part was the best, earthquake things were cool, sometimes lookd a bit unsynced, but it was nice :D
About stunting, I don't know a shit about it but liked precs.
Kudos to my crew for making this vid, keep improving guys, we're all so proud of it :a-cheer:
-
@Phamus On the first part you can see huge black banners both on top and bottom which is also messing up the resolution. On the third part you can see huge white banners, both top and bottom. Banners is a basic English word. What joke exactly are you joking about? The super dark CCs? That's not a joke, mainstream SA editing uses super dark CCs. And what do you mean disgusting? The joke?
And lastly, I have not said anything labourious, these things were easy to see, and therefore not hard to comment about. Stop using Google translator to try and express yourself, you clearly have no clue on how to use those words :3
-
HAAHAHAHAH GOOGLE TRANSLATOR?
I live in London, you bizarre looking viking.
I go to school, I'm well educated. Do not judge me in anyway do you understand?
And you call those banners? And you're telling me I'm the one in need of Google translator.
Mainstream SA editing uses super dark CC's is the biggest myth. You're implying that to enrich your overall capability of contrasting in an argument by having the sincerity to conclude on your point by saying that "You clearly have no clue on how to use those words" is sad. A southern grotesque-looking man would have more knowledge than you, madam.
-
Well since this is not about the actual video anymore you can scold me through PMs furtheron, Phamus. :wacko:
-
I'd rather not, with other 160PM's it's enough. We should end with this sillyness, hence the fact that I've just looked at your carebox which looks like this: []
And it's empty.
-
It's much too overedited for me but I know many guys will think it very cool. Just not my taste really. :P
-
It's much too overedited for me but I know many guys will think it very cool. Just not my taste really. :P
:(
maybe clean edit collab next time :P
-
nvm.
To sum up this vid in one emoticon: :wacko:
-
Furious - Static :wub:
First part has a good CC but I'm confused whit the angles, one angle, another angle, one angle another angle and following...
Anyway the part is good, too dark but, so what?
Second part, oh my god
I love the second part, I love the song, I love the Dubstep editing, is, is... sexy.
I love you Static.
Third part too is awesome
Is one of the best parts on the video, always I love that. -I love the CC-
Same has static, I love you more Furious♥
Four part
I didn't like it, I don't know why, one thing make me didn't like this.
Don't for the CC or the Dark only, I don't know why I didn't like it, sorry :wacko:
Five part
I laugh, I like, I love the part. Awesome CC is awesome.
Nice Phamus :3.
ALWAYS, Nice organization & video Phamus!
I like the songs, but more the Furious song!
Nice video guys, keep it up!
Who can tell me the songs? :3
-
ok,that my opinion about the edit :euro:
eXe:
GREAT INTRO effects! but cc is dark,i cant clearly see the MAGIC text :P
main part of yours:really great effects :wub: but almost not see your pan crop work,just this a bit not nice i think :P
really great first dude :wub:
Static:
WOW,really great CC :|
and effects are so amazing! and fking like this LA Roax/Skrillex Song :wub:
yea..the song is very complexity i think,just think you should put more effects. :ninja:
ex:1:58-2:03 really great part of the music..but there is black :|
however,still amazing!!
Furious:
nice start!2:43-2:44 pan crop FKING awesome!! really love your pan crop work :wub:
what a pity,you just edit 4 stunts :(
DJK:
Oh..I do not want to comment for mine.. just want to say"I should not choose to use this song,that really not crazy <_<"
Phamus:
YEA! really diversification :wub: :wub:
the expand effect really awesome!!
the BB text of the 5:18 and 4:49-4:51,is my favorite :wub: :wub:
really love this part,great final ;D
YEA,really awesome WL production! and nice GTAS and WOS stunters :cc_detective:
-
HAAHAHAHAH GOOGLE TRANSLATOR?
I live in London, you bizarre looking viking.
I go to school, I'm well educated. Do not judge me in anyway do you understand?
And you call those banners? And you're telling me I'm the one in need of Google translator.
Mainstream SA editing uses super dark CC's is the biggest myth. You're implying that to enrich your overall capability of contrasting in an argument by having the sincerity to conclude on your point by saying that "You clearly have no clue on how to use those words" is sad. A southern grotesque-looking man would have more knowledge than you, madam.
vikings are awesome.
video:
Music overall 0/10
dont like the music, not my taste
editing 5/10
overedited imo. i give you 5 points for the hard work. well it looks like much work to me.
sunts 8/10
stunts were enjoyable. Opener (static's stunt) was just horrible, that "SCM stuck method" makes me so angry i cant even tell you. Also dont know why that stunt is even the opener / in the video.
-
editing 5/10
overedited imo. i give you 5 points for the hard work. well it looks like much work to me.
It's an overedit collab.
-
editing 5/10
overedited imo. i give you 5 points for the hard work. well it looks like much work to me.
It's an overedit collab.
Speaking here,i think you should say this message in the topic :P
-
My 1st stunt got cut :( I landed the precision part lol, but my 2nd for the finisher :wub:.
Second half of the video is my favorite.
Nicely done guys =).
-
I dont think the editing is bad (its quite good if you like to watch overdits), BUT you all should get a bit more handling of the effects, and probably think more about "where do I place them?" to make them fit to the video, I also think that StatiCs part is the best in the video,
anyways, cool video guys^^
-
sorry guys but that was absolutely terrible, i can see you put a lot of work into this but it's just unwatchable :neen: next time try to focus more on making an enjoyable video instead of putting on every beat as many effects as you can.
-
Watching with relatively high expectations. You'll get a full review once I'm done.
Oh and Gavran, don't want to get involved in your arguments, but it's not called a banner, it's called a border :cheersad:
-
Alright, here's what I think about your individual editings (as I feel this is a primarily editing collar I won't focus on the stunts):
eXe
Actually I enjoyed it more than any other editing by you. It seems like you're starting to take my advice about effect controlling, but I still think that your part falls really short of what it could've been. With such a choice of CC and soundtrack you created a platform for something that'd go great in an overediting video, as it combines calm sounds with plenty of sound effects. However, despite the fact that a lot of your effects weren't bad, the video was all in all obnoxious. You put loads of effects everywhere, whereas I think that it would have been much better if you had a heavy part followed by a calm part, and so on. Not only it keeps the overedit part from getting boring (it really did in your part), it also gives everyone an opportunity to clearly see the stunts. And speaking of which, the stunts were really hard to understand, because of your rapid camera angle changes. However, I think you should definitely try out a few more edits with music like this, just learn that you are the one who controls the editing, and don't put effects just for the sake of effects.
7/10
StatiC
You probably already know this track is old, and even though I feel that Beat did it much more justice, I still enjoyed your part a lot. The CC choice was really good, although it was too dark at some spots. (not saying you should have changed it, but merely fine-tuned it for some specific clips to give more vision) I think you missed out on some good places where you could have applied effects, and at some points you got a little uncreative (mostly the parts with TV Simulator), but all in all this editing went along with the music well, and the camera angles were all decent.
8/10
Furious
It could have had potential (i spotted quite a few good moments and effects), but the poor and unfitting CC combined with that ugly border completely ruined it. Technical editings are all good, but if they're not backed up by solid elements like these, then the video is never as enjoyable as it could have been. Shame, because your music choice was the best. Another point you could work on is using the artbeats in a more fitting way, I mean, those scratches seemed really out of place for me. Well, nothing more to say I guess... Hope you listen to my advice and do it better next time.
6.5/10
D.JacK
Ahh, another great oldie track! Same as for StatiC, I think that the original editor (Rusch) did a better job, but that's mosty because he didn't make it so monotonous. You've obviously had great potential to make an epic part, but to me it's "just" awesome. You did a great job though, all of your effects were well synchronized to the music, the colors were fine, and the camera angles were for the most part good. The only bad thing about your editing is that it got a little predictable as the part went on, you used a lot of similar effect combos. They were all good, but just look at Rusch's editing to this music - he didn't have many effects, but they were all fitting and diversified: that's why he did a better job.
9/10
Phamus
It was my favourite part, great job! The thing I liked the most was that you didn't sacrifice the flow for the effects' sake, you picked good spots to place most of them and they were fitting for the most part. The camera angles were also okay, the music picked was nice. The only part I disliked was the Brazil interlude, if you're gonna make interludes like that at least make them fit good. That one felt totally out of place. But yeah, other than that, great job, keep trying to make your stuff more polished, but you're definitely on the right track!
9/10
All in all I'm satisfied with this video, although my expectations haven't been fully met. Main advice to all of you, and anyone else who wants to try overediting - Don't lose focus and control. Don't use effects for the sake of effects, but pick a good and fitting spot for them. Never forget about elements such as CC's - they're essential to a good watch, no matter what the video type is. Keep in mind that overediting can always be enjoyable, you just need to know to overedit cleverly.
-
I didn't like it at all to be honest. There's nothing wrong with using lots of effects but overediting isn't a style, it's something you should try to avoid, and it shows. It's just all over the place, and the style of the video had no real identity other than being 'overedited', because you weren't all going for a central theme. I thought StatiC's editing was by far the best, it certainly had the strongest theme to it. If you all had adopted his theme the video would have been more consistent, but having said that I didn't like any of the edits at all. It just looks bad to see so many boring effects, and the whole pacing of clips was just boring, as well as random camera angles etc. All overediting can achieve is distracting from the stunts, and nobody's watching the video to see you place some filters on a timeline and move some sliders around.
Sorry if I'm being harsh but I just don't get why people overedit, only use effects if they're making the video better. You don't even need to use CC's if you don't want to, you should only be using colour correction to correct the colours of your footage (GTA doesn't need correcting), or to give the video a certain 'look' to it.
-
HAAHAHAHAH GOOGLE TRANSLATOR?
I live in London, you bizarre looking viking.
I go to school, I'm well educated. Do not judge me in anyway do you understand?
And you call those banners? And you're telling me I'm the one in need of Google translator.
Mainstream SA editing uses super dark CC's is the biggest myth. You're implying that to enrich your overall capability of contrasting in an argument by having the sincerity to conclude on your point by saying that "You clearly have no clue on how to use those words" is sad. A southern grotesque-looking man would have more knowledge than you, madam.
(http://jackoroma3.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/door.jpg)
There's the door. Now get out.
OT:
The editing made this video more challenging to watch than it was entertaining or even enjoyable. I can understand how you might feel the need to stand out from the crowd, but this is not quite how it's done.
-
Guys, I'm fucking :blink: at the moment.
I'm in school and I can't wait to get home and watch this video with sound. I'm very proud of you guys, and remember that the November Member's Awards are comming. Take into account that this video will be the key to your results. I hope to see you soon my friends.
Your crazy leader, iAndy.
Cheers!
-
Wow, i'm impressed by your work guys :)
Great video and the best part is that it doesn't really seems that it's edited by 4 different people!
Really a topnotch job!
-
Sorry but I dont find anything positive to say about this vid :L I didnt like the edit, couldnt see half of the stunts, didnt enjoy 1 bit, also why 1 of my stunts wasnt used ? Not very proud to be part of this, but i say gj anyways <_<
-
eXe
Actually I enjoyed it more than any other editing by you. It seems like you're starting to take my advice about effect controlling, but I still think that your part falls really short of what it could've been. With such a choice of CC and soundtrack you created a platform for something that'd go great in an overediting video, as it combines calm sounds with plenty of sound effects. However, despite the fact that a lot of your effects weren't bad, the video was all in all obnoxious. You put loads of effects everywhere, whereas I think that it would have been much better if you had a heavy part followed by a calm part, and so on. Not only it keeps the overedit part from getting boring (it really did in your part), it also gives everyone an opportunity to clearly see the stunts. And speaking of which, the stunts were really hard to understand, because of your rapid camera angle changes. However, I think you should definitely try out a few more edits with music like this, just learn that you are the one who controls the editing, and don't put effects just for the sake of effects.
7/10
thank' you , but if u know , i'm a CSS editor .. SA is totally different. My "effects" are pretty bad , but i try to find new effects with a good look. And yeah , I tried to respect your advice. thanks you :jajaja:
-
HAAHAHAHAH GOOGLE TRANSLATOR?
I live in London, you bizarre looking viking.
I go to school, I'm well educated. Do not judge me in anyway do you understand?
And you call those banners? And you're telling me I'm the one in need of Google translator.
Mainstream SA editing uses super dark CC's is the biggest myth. You're implying that to enrich your overall capability of contrasting in an argument by having the sincerity to conclude on your point by saying that "You clearly have no clue on how to use those words" is sad. A southern grotesque-looking man would have more knowledge than you, madam.
(http://jackoroma3.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/door.jpg)
There's the door. Now get out.
OT:
The editing made this video more challenging to watch than it was entertaining or even enjoyable. I can understand how you might feel the need to stand out from the crowd, but this is not quite how it's done.
*clap clap*
Well done for jumping into an argument which has already been finished?
Chocolate chip cookie? Or custard cream biscuit?
-
I really love you WL you have an awesome editors and style :wub:
But this ... I'm totaly disappointed guys :( I was think that gonna be better than SKRILLEX but I'm wrong. This wasn't very bad but it's very unsynced imo :L Anyway my fav was StatiC part but still have what to do :) anyway good job guys ! But as I already says I'm totaly disappointed :(
Edit : btw some great stunts :happy:
-
People likes us, wouldn't think to be better than SKRILLEX.
That video is just amazing.
But on the other hand, I thank you for your sincere review, which gives me inspiration to step down from ver-editing and track back to just clean, and simple edits.
-
People likes us, wouldn't think to be better than SKRILLEX.
That video is just amazing.
But on the other hand, I thank you for your sincere review, which gives me inspiration to step down from ver-editing and track back to just clean, and simple edits.
not exactly. I mean I was think eXe will make awesome overedit because he can make much more better, also StatiC too and you, but for Furious I'm not saying it was really fucking bad but your clean edits are much more better :neen:
-
Yes I understand alien.
But blame me, I'm the one who forgot to mention that this was Furious' first over-edit as he wanted to get some experience.
-
Furious did a great work,the complexity better than me. i think :cc_detective:
I dont think his editing is bad. otherwise,awesome!
oh..and Phamus,update your sign plz :P
and download done? :o
D.JacK
Ahh, another great oldie track! Same as for StatiC, I think that the original editor (Rusch) did a better job, but that's mosty because he didn't make it so monotonous. You've obviously had great potential to make an epic part, but to me it's "just" awesome. You did a great job though, all of your effects were well synchronized to the music, the colors were fine, and the camera angles were for the most part good. The only bad thing about your editing is that it got a little predictable as the part went on, you used a lot of similar effect combos. They were all good, but just look at Rusch's editing to this music - he didn't have many effects, but they were all fitting and diversified: that's why he did a better job.
oh WOW,thx for the comment in detail!!
and R69 really amazing! btw which video he used same music plz? :L
just want wtach how did he to interpret this music :jajaja:
-
Nice vid guys, like static cc, however :happy:
BRAZIIL :wub:
-
Nice vid guys, like static cc, however :happy:
BRAZIIL :wub:
Hehehe :3
-
nice video, pretty CC's, i Love the Phamus part (:
BRAZIL² :wub:
nice edit
eXe, Static, Furious, D. Jack and phamus
-
oh WOW,thx for the comment in detail!!
and R69 really amazing! btw which video he used same music plz? :L
just want wtach how did he to interpret this music :jajaja:
[noembed]Rusch Hour 3 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdtGSVhpKas#ws)[/noembed], 03:01-03:34
and no problem :3
-
Thanks for all guys for positive or negative comments about my editing
+ that was my first overedit :lol:
ohh D.JacK thanks, you're awesome :wub:
-
oh WOW,thx for the comment in detail!!
and R69 really amazing! btw which video he used same music plz? :L
just want wtach how did he to interpret this music :jajaja:
[noembed]Rusch Hour 3 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdtGSVhpKas#ws)[/noembed], 03:01-03:34
and no problem :3
om..i watched this video many times,but I forgot he used this song :ninja:
thank you,dude. and sorry to R69 :P
-
the intro was little bit bad ... Static's opener in Static's part is old by Xease .. anyways i still love this PSM. Most like Static's part , overall not bad :euro: good job guys
-
after intro it was closed, sry :|
-
you guys give your selfs awards just like that ?
-
you guys give your selfs awards just like that ?
The awards were planned before this video.
It's just our leader's way to congratulate us, I hope there isn't anything wrong.
-
nothing is wrong, was just wondering, anywayz the video was neat, some great editing with some okish stunts, good job, alot of improvement in the crew
-
Oh my god :lol:
Will watch the video now
EDIT: Yeah the editing was the best part of the video eventhough I didn't like most of the songs and CCs used *awaits for flame*
-
lol Phamus, thanks for supplying my daily dose of laughs. (http://www.coinsgbforum.com/public/style_emoticons/default/th_ThumbsUp.gif)
anyways about the video: it was weird how much it varied, this goes for stunting as well as editing. Some stunts were great and looked really good, but some stunts were old or looked as if SA ran out of spots so you just landed that instead. The editing had some really good parts, but some really annoying parts that nearly gave me headaches as well. Sometimes you really got into the flow of things just to have it all smashed away a few seconds later with an overuse of unnecessary effects. I don't want to get too specific, as I clearly have no clue what I'm talking about, but from a "consumer" point of view, it felt that way.
-
The first part was liak :wacko:
even though i got very opener cant see shit in my stunt, or nametags if there are any on exe's part :<
edit: actually almost any stunts lol.
btw u gonna up this on wos forums phasmus
-
you guys give your selfs awards just like that ?
The awards were planned before this video.
It's just our leader's way to congratulate us, I hope there isn't anything wrong.
We actually wanted a public vote, members and no-members can vote, but anyways he wanted to do it like more "private".
-
The edit by StatiC was awesome!!
And I loved Samba de janeiro for Syny :lol:
Awesome song + awesome edit = results in awesome video good job, shame I couldn't send something :cheersad:
Stunts: Mak / Mike stood out for me with the ambulance stunt
Lost the p2b2wallride2bridge in LS
Lost the bump2precision in LV ( I landed with FCR) :|
-
Awesome video, I loved the all parts exept the eXe part ;)
4:55 haha, great job here Phamus, but I hate samba :euro:
Now the white label is a great editing crew.
This crew is improving all and also is grow up really fast, a great future is coming.
-
The edit by StatiC was awesome!!
And I loved Samba de janeiro for Syny :lol:
Awesome song + awesome edit = results in awesome video good job, shame I couldn't send something :cheersad:
Stunts: Mak / Mike stood out for me with the ambulance stunt
Lost the p2b2wallride2bridge in LS
Lost the bump2precision in LV ( I landed with FCR) :|
:O and i though my stunts were all sucky, Thanks :P
-
furious have a nice future in overedit :ajaja:
-
OVEREDITING BLABLABLABLABA OMFG
... jesus I fucking hate what GTAS editing has become. These days there are billions of short editing preview lulzwat audio organized bla review dubstep blubb test overeditz000z0z0rrr skrillex crew directed by beat shit clips.
People need to realize that editing ain't a competition at all. I seriously don't mind videos being bombed with effects, but do it fucking properly and more well thought. Adding random effects upon clips kind of became like dick measuring. Seriously, if you just want a video filled with crap, I got a hot tip for ya, check this out:
mAyhEm for Sony Vegas Pro 8/9 software (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIhW_smoknQ#ws)
Instructions: Get a pirate copy of the plugin. Install it on your computer. Apply the plugin to your whole video. Render, upload and post it at GTAS. Congratulations, you now got the longest dick around with almost no effort. :)
The only guys around GTAS which did well with a shitload of effects on their videos are still Bujutzustyle & downight imo.
Sorry for not really commenting the video, but all in all I didn't like it for obvious reasons.
-
xD you exaggerate A LOT.
whut?competition...we did this for fun,lol!?
you even use some unnecassery effects (rh3) ,IMO ...its just...editing man,everyone have his own style...
just let us use as much effects as we want to and don't make such stupid comments to this...
you thing you're the god of editing and know how to do it all right and have to criticize everything in an exaggerated way?
that was really..omg i dunno what to say -.-
-
xD you exaggerate A LOT.
whut?competition...we did this for fun,lol!?
you even use some unnecassery effects (rh3) ,IMO ...its just...editing man,everyone have his own style...
just let us use as much effects as we want to and don't make such stupid comments to this...
you thing you're the god of editing and know how to do it all right and have to criticize everything in an exaggerated way?
that was really..omg i dunno what to say -.-
just agree.
-
OVEREDITING BLABLABLABLABA OMFG
... jesus I fucking hate what GTAS editing has become. These days there are billions of short editing preview lulzwat audio organized bla review dubstep blubb test overeditz000z0z0rrr skrillex crew directed by beat shit clips.
People need to realize that editing ain't a competition at all. I seriously don't mind videos being bombed with effects, but do it fucking properly and more well thought. Adding random effects upon clips kind of became like dick measuring. Seriously, if you just want a video filled with crap, I got a hot tip for ya, check this out:
mAyhEm for Sony Vegas Pro 8/9 software (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIhW_smoknQ#ws)
Instructions: Get a pirate copy of the plugin. Install it on your computer. Apply the plugin to your whole video. Render, upload and post it at GTAS. Congratulations, you now got the longest dick around with almost no effort. :)
The only guys around GTAS which did well with a shitload of effects on their videos are still Bujutzustyle & downight imo.
Sorry for not really commenting the video, but all in all I didn't like it for obvious reasons.
Fix your purple CC's then come back to me ok?
Dickhead.
-
Maybe you should stop raging at everyone, Phallus. ;)
-
Never met anybody called Phallus. Have you?
-
OVEREDITING BLABLABLABLABA OMFG
... jesus I fucking hate what GTAS editing has become. These days there are billions of short editing preview lulzwat audio organized bla review dubstep blubb test overeditz000z0z0rrr skrillex crew directed by beat shit clips.
People need to realize that editing ain't a competition at all. I seriously don't mind videos being bombed with effects, but do it fucking properly and more well thought. Adding random effects upon clips kind of became like dick measuring. Seriously, if you just want a video filled with crap, I got a hot tip for ya, check this out:
mAyhEm for Sony Vegas Pro 8/9 software (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIhW_smoknQ#ws)
Instructions: Get a pirate copy of the plugin. Install it on your computer. Apply the plugin to your whole video. Render, upload and post it at GTAS. Congratulations, you now got the longest dick around with almost no effort. :)
The only guys around GTAS which did well with a shitload of effects on their videos are still Bujutzustyle & downight imo.
Sorry for not really commenting the video, but all in all I didn't like it for obvious reasons.
Fix your purple CC's then come back to me ok?
Dickhead.
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
What is Dickhead? ^^
-
OVEREDITING BLABLABLABLABA OMFG
... jesus I fucking hate what GTAS editing has become. These days there are billions of short editing preview lulzwat audio organized bla review dubstep blubb test overeditz000z0z0rrr skrillex crew directed by beat shit clips.
People need to realize that editing ain't a competition at all. I seriously don't mind videos being bombed with effects, but do it fucking properly and more well thought. Adding random effects upon clips kind of became like dick measuring. Seriously, if you just want a video filled with crap, I got a hot tip for ya, check this out:
mAyhEm for Sony Vegas Pro 8/9 software (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIhW_smoknQ#ws)
Instructions: Get a pirate copy of the plugin. Install it on your computer. Apply the plugin to your whole video. Render, upload and post it at GTAS. Congratulations, you now got the longest dick around with almost no effort. :)
The only guys around GTAS which did well with a shitload of effects on their videos are still Bujutzustyle & downight imo.
Sorry for not really commenting the video, but all in all I didn't like it for obvious reasons.
Fix your purple CC's then come back to me ok?
Dickhead.
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
What is Dickhead? ^^
Look at R. face :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
Am i stupid ? :|
-
OVEREDITING BLABLABLABLABA OMFG
... jesus I fucking hate what GTAS editing has become. These days there are billions of short editing preview lulzwat audio organized bla review dubstep blubb test overeditz000z0z0rrr skrillex crew directed by beat shit clips.
People need to realize that editing ain't a competition at all. I seriously don't mind videos being bombed with effects, but do it fucking properly and more well thought. Adding random effects upon clips kind of became like dick measuring. Seriously, if you just want a video filled with crap, I got a hot tip for ya, check this out:
mAyhEm for Sony Vegas Pro 8/9 software (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIhW_smoknQ#ws)
Instructions: Get a pirate copy of the plugin. Install it on your computer. Apply the plugin to your whole video. Render, upload and post it at GTAS. Congratulations, you now got the longest dick around with almost no effort. :)
The only guys around GTAS which did well with a shitload of effects on their videos are still Bujutzustyle & downight imo.
Sorry for not really commenting the video, but all in all I didn't like it for obvious reasons.
Fix your purple CC's then come back to me ok?
Dickhead.
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
What is Dickhead? ^^
Look at R. face :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
im i stupid ? :|
Oh, ok. Thanks Furious :lol: :lol: :lol:
-
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: WHY :lol: :lol: :lol: AM I :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: LAUGHING :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
-
God seriously, Rusch has a valid point and you just outrage without even considering his post. What's the point of editing stunts if you're not even showing them properly? Why won't you use some other background clip then? This is not editing-themed forums, get rid of those effects if you're still gonna post in here 'cause a lot of people are having hard time going through those videos.
-
God seriously, Rusch has a valid point and you just outrage without even considering his post. What's the point of editing stunts if you're not even showing them properly? Why won't you use some other background clip then? This is not editing-themed forums, get rid of those effects if you're still gonna post in here 'cause a lot of people are having hard time going through those videos.
Actually, they have the right to post whatever they want in here as long as it is an Un-Modded SA video. There don't exist any editing rules and everyone will have a problem with some kind of editing as we're all different.
What Rusch said was somewhat valid (his point of editing more "cleverly" instead of flurrying the video with effects just for the heck of it was kinda the same as mine) but the approach was totally off and not constructive at all. All in all, it's more like a crap premise resulting in crap responses. Both sides' fault and I don't think that's the way a moderator should criticize other forum members - doesn't set a good example. Ain't no denying that he's a far more experienced editor and forum member overall, but that doesn't give him the right to write a post like that.
Just being objective, sorry Dre :euro: Most of your posts are quite fine, so I know this is just a rare exception.
-
Try to focus on actually showing the entire stunts than adding cool effects. When watching a vid I usually watch it without sound to get a good view of the stunts and then rewatch it with the music used in the video. Try not using too bright or too dark colors because it gets very annoying after a while. Better luck on your next video :)
-
Actually, they have the right to post whatever they want in here as long as it is an Un-Modded SA video. There don't exist any editing rules and everyone will have a problem with some kind of editing as we're all different.
But what's the point of it if we can't see what's happening? This whole fashion for dubstep music and fucking shitload of effects all over the screen makes me sick. There obviously is some limited tolerance towards number of effects as long as the stunt itself is clear enough but seriously, nowadays there are more pseudo editing tests than stunting videos themselves in this section. People tend to cover up the stunting part with useless visuals that make the video less enjoyable watching it stunting-wise which is priority in this section in case you didn't realize. <_<
-
Actually, they have the right to post whatever they want in here as long as it is an Un-Modded SA video. There don't exist any editing rules and everyone will have a problem with some kind of editing as we're all different.
But what's the point of it if we can't see what's happening? This whole fashion for dubstep music and fucking shitload of effects all over the screen makes me sick. There obviously is some limited tolerance towards number of effects as long as the stunt itself is clear enough but seriously, nowadays there are more pseudo editing tests than stunting videos themselves in this section. People tend to cover up the stunting part with useless visuals that make the video less enjoyable watching it stunting-wise which is priority in this section in case you didn't realize. <_<
Okay. Now consider the opposite example of a person X who fucking hates videos without an effect placed on every spot it "should" be, or simply people who don't find stunt videos engaging or entertaining at all without some special effectage to them. I've met people around who were like that during these 3 years. Should their opinion be cast aside? Just notice that there is subjectiveness you've added to your reply.
Now I do agree with you that the lot of videos are nowadays really short and don't really do the stunts much good. But that was bound to happen, ever since leftover videos became a commodity. The point is that you can't deny anyone the right to post their San Andreas production in the SA Un-Modded Videos section, if their video doesn't contain any modded stunts. That's simply it. Nobody mentioned any priorities.
We've taken up way too much of these guys' topic with our arguments and I'm sure that their hard work deserves more real video replies instead of our discussion. I have an opinion just like you do, it's not much different from yours, but I am obliged to be objective about it as I'm a moderator (and because I don't want to deny anyone the right to anything - nobody denied me to post my ugly "experiments" back when I was fresh). So, let's leave it at that and if there's anything you'd like to ask/suggest, use PM.
Cheers.
-
just one more thing:
But what's the point of it if we can't see what's happening? This whole fashion for dubstep music and fucking shitload of effects all over the screen makes me sick. There obviously is some limited tolerance towards number of effects as long as the stunt itself is clear enough but seriously, nowadays there are more pseudo editing tests than stunting videos themselves in this section. People tend to cover up the stunting part with useless visuals that make the video less enjoyable watching it stunting-wise which is priority in this section in case you didn't realize. <_<
there are some thing i dunno if you recognized them...
this collab wasn't supposed to be an overedit collab...it was supposed to be an OVERedit collab,got it?
second thing...lots of the stunts were actually sent to other collabs before..
for me (so my part) i just put much effects on the spots that were actually old or already released...
e.g Flippas stunt in lv..is old like hell..so why let people cry of old stunts..better to overedit (imo)
in my eyes...i can see all stunts and also see if they were hard,creative,awesome whatever...
so for ALL people that can't see the stunts correctly: buy a new screen with a better resolution,go on youtube,click on 720p and make the video bigger by clicking a butten in the left lower corner.
k thx bye
-
Fix your purple CC's then come back to me ok?
Dickhead.
EHEH, EHEH. You so cool now, can I be your friend please?
-
just want say thx any comment even the annoying.bcz your comments all are be useful.
i just a bit cant agree the "Not constructive mere expression of negative thoughts"
but there thoughts i will still remember.
not more to say,i know all the comment will let's be better. :)
-
Fix your purple CC's then come back to me ok?
Dickhead.
Ok at first you made me laugh and I kind of agreed with you, but now you are acting like a fucking dumbass. If you can't even accept the simplest of criticism then I don't know what's left for you. Learn to respect peoples opinions and stop acting like a fucking keyboard hero.
and this has nothing to do with Rusch being a "veteran", it has to do with your ignorant way of looking at things and the only response you have is based out of flawed logics (fallacies if you are familiar with that term)
-
Just noticed..
Before D.Jack's part
I SENSE WAROW!
-
Just noticed..
Before D.Jack's part
I SENSE WAROW!
same here :lol:
-
instead of writing back shit comments about rusch tip for you, you should be glad he did, i dont get it, you are still new to editing, when some one who is professional in editing and has more experiences than you and ALL of his edits amaze 95% of the community, you should take that tip, shut up, and make use of it
sorry for the rage, but had to get my words out
-
Maybe you should stop raging at everyone, Phallus. ;)
hahahahahahahahahaah!!!!!!!!!!!
:lol:
Anyway, what's up with these fucked up editings to dubstep songs nowadays? Seriously, I'm not a 1337 pro editor but these things are just crossing the line...... Please people get it, shitty dubstep songs and over-editing =/= cool
At least choose a decent song and make it somewhat a watchable stunting video. My opinion, thanks.
EDIT: I also agree what Rusch said. He made a valid point, yes he did rage a bit, but how to prove it to you guys that this isn't fun anymore? You are trying way too hard, it is clear as a crystal. Believe me, simple edits are much more effective.
-
disagreement, not all dupstep edits are not cool, take Skrillex collab for example, it was great, editing to dubstep can be great if effects were used right
-
First SA vid I've watched in a long time, so the stunts weren't half bad for me. I'm so out of the loop with SA stunting that I can't tell what's old and what isn't - which is actually a pretty good place to be.
However, this thing was WAAAAAAY too over-edited. Effects and all are good, but when you're making that the driving force of your vid (which is how it turned out, considering the stunts themselves were often drowned almost completely out by too many effects gags) the whole thing just turns out to be a mess. Keep in mind that this is a stunting forum, not an editing one. People want to see the stunts first and foremost. The editing is just a way to tie them all together.
Good effort stunting wise, but clean edits ftw!
-
Okay you know what.
I'm gonna give up overediting, and switch back to cleanwise.
I sort of agree with all of you, and I'm guessing overediting isn't my thing, so yes, I apologize, and I will shape up my edits and my attitude in the future.
-
All these years after Wergild, I have realized that editing to dubstep is just Ghost's privilege. Everything after Wegild was crap and plagiarism, this video is no exception. Stunting was extremely bad also, plus I haven't seen most of the stunts. Overall, this was one of the worst videos in the history of GTAstunting.
-
....in your opinion.
-
....in your opinion.
Yes, in my opinion.
-
Thanks for being specific. <_<
-
Thanks for being specific. <_<
Thank you for being so kind.
-
flamewar_^
instead of being a community and giving CONSTRUCTIVE CRITISM a lot of you are crying for cookies. I dont get it,
with your behavior gtastunting wont be a "community" in some months/years anymore, because everyone here is whining and taking things too serious.
ciao and sorry for my gayenglish
-
flamewar_^
instead of being a community and giving CONSTRUCTIVE CRITISM a lot of you are crying for cookies. I dont get it,
with your behavior gtastunting wont be a "community" in some months/years anymore, because everyone here is whining and taking things too serious.
ciao and sorry for my gayenglish
I love you.
-
All these years after Wergild, I have realized that editing to dubstep is just Ghost's privilege. Everything after Wegild was crap and plagiarism, this video is no exception. Stunting was extremely bad also, plus I haven't seen most of the stunts. Overall, this was one of the worst videos in the history of GTAstunting.
what is GTAstunting? I just know GTAStunting. :L
-
All these years after Wergild, I have realized that editing to dubstep is just Ghost's privilege. Everything after Wegild was crap and plagiarism, this video is no exception. Stunting was extremely bad also, plus I haven't seen most of the stunts. Overall, this was one of the worst videos in the history of GTAstunting.
what is GTAstunting? I just know GTAStunting. :L
That's because you are infinitely wise, just like your friend Phamus. It's an honour to talk with you.
-
I've already apologized for my earlier actions, feel free to criticize me more.
-
i noticed that you have great English phamus btw, nice to see that
-
Woah lol, I didn't expect such a discussion going on. First off, thanks for insulting me - that really shows backbones guys. My post actually wasn't even directed directly towards anybody, instead it's for the masses. I just felt like posting that here after watching the video, could've been elsewhere too (well, it's kinda related critism though). If you think it was meant in a conceited way, no it wasn't. As I said it before, editing ain't a competition ffs. Many people randomly seem to mess up their videos which is really annoying nowadays. Basically they indeed just try too hard.
-
Wow the soundtrack was terrible! I don't understand how you would want to edit to this. Finisher could've been awesome hadn't he landed upside down :(
-
(http://i43.tinypic.com/fmlys3.jpg)
-
I saw that this thread has 7 pages,. and i thought hey must be something good, well i liked the video tbh, the best for me was Furious, but others were cool aswell :)
And Gavran you should shut the fuck up for once, always complaining asswipe.
-
What's the problem with Gavran complaining? He has the to right to complain as much as he wants. Better watch your mouth Veno.
-
(http://images.cheezburger.com/completestore/2011/12/6/8dd5c2e1-9088-4216-bdcc-32bb4dc68cb1.png)
bye
-
You're implying that to enrich your overall capability of contrasting in an argument by having the sincerity to conclude on your point by saying that "You clearly have no clue on how to use those words" is sad.
Might be one of the funniest things I've ever read on GTAS.
-
@Red in a bad way? <_< probably.
@Neotec HAHAHAAHAHAHAHAAH no.
-
Phamus stop responding, you apologized at first but now you are making it even worse. You are stuck in an infinite loop and if you don't shut it you'll only damage yourself.
This was a word of advice, so don't get offended by it and then give me a witty response.
-
Alright my bad.
I guess I'll let the rest of you insult the hell out of me however much you'd like.
Thanks Genyus, my genious.
-
Bad manner leads to bad manners, it's an infinite loop. Quite frankly if you refuse to take critisism and constructive critisism, stop editing immediately because there are so many ways to edit, and there will always be somebody who will dislike it. Either take this as me trying to help you, or comprehend it like you've done earlier and see it as an insult.
-
Okay I'm sorry dammit... I'm defenseless what else can I do.
-
Just swallow it? Nobody's perfect. You are allowed to respond to people but the way you do it is out of proportion. Sure some people may come over as twats to you, but act like the better man and don't lower your standards.
As for the constructive criticism, people are only trying to help you out for your next videos, so a "Okay, thanks for the words I'll try better in my next video" would suffice.
-
Hell yeah, I live in a manor and I'm fine with that.
The first part was terrible and the rest was okey. Good job guys for your persistence. :)
-
What's the problem with Gavran complaining? He has the to right to complain as much as he wants. Better watch your mouth Veno.
Don't you even dare tell me to watch my mouth, you're no better Kai.
I overreacted about Gavran, sorry to you.
But it really sucks to see al the rage here, and it makes to rage me aswell :<
-
Yes I am no better but that doesn't mean that you have to be the same ^_^
Ontopic nao I feel like this has been derailed too much again.