GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: Fugitive on October 01, 2006, 12:44:23 AM
-
Round 1 - Battle 5 - Voting poll
UnderDetention vs. rekees
Project: Signature
Theme: Mummies (by Fugitive)
Rules: http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=15366 (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=15366)- Anyone can vote.
- You must have a valid reason. If you will only say "My vote goes to XYZ", your vote won't be counted.
- Competitors cannot vote in their own battles.
- You must have more then 30 posts to be able to vote.
- You have 24 hours to vote.
UnderDetention's:
[img]http://img471.imageshack.us/img471/1981/mummiesax4.jpg\" border=\"0\" alt=\"IPB Image\" /]
rekees':
[img]http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f286/rekees/ImageBot/rekees7.jpg\" border=\"0\" alt=\"IPB Image\" /]
Good luck!
-
I vote underdetention's because rekees has to much empty space in it.
-
UnderDetention's:
+ Good balance of empty space
- The quality of the renders
- No sense of depth at all
- The focus
- The composition
- The text
- Not interesting
rekees':
+ Blending
+ It has a focal
- Too much empty space
- The quality of the render
My vote goes to...
Rekees. Even though it has too much empty space, it looks better in my eyes.
-
I vote UnderDetention because i don't like reekees's colors.
-
Both lack alot of elements that define a good sig,
My vite goes to Rekkee's
It seems , and i emphasize seems's , to have a better sense of composition and balance
-
UnderDetention's:
+ Good balance of empty space
- The text
Whats wrong with the text?
Is it cause you can't understand it right away?
I knew i was going out on a limb with it >_>
-
UnderDetention's I like the collors and its stylish
-
UnderDetention's:
+ Good balance of empty space
- The text
Whats wrong with the text?
Is it cause you can't understand it right away?
I knew i was going out on a limb with it >_>
No, it doesn't look good, that's all.
-
My vote goes to UnderDetention, no because I specially like it, but because the rekees' is too empty
-
My vote goes to UnderDetention, no because I specially like it, but because the rekees' is too empty
coulnt really make a good sig with mummies.. plus even if i did find a mummy picture, i would have to render it.. and im bad at rendering...
would mothers be allowed instead of those creepy ancien mummies?
-
Lol, yeah, thatd be a good idea.
Get a pic of a mom holding cookies on a pan with an apron xD
I have a crazy render secret nobody shall know
-
Well, Honestly im surprised and a little sad by this contest.
I look at Rek's current sig, and then the entry he put up and its like night and day...or good and horrible, which ever you wish.
But that aside I do need to vote so lets do it this way,
My vote goes to Under, his sig shows the actual theme more so then rek's abomination of a signature.
Cheers
-
I must admit, this is probably as far as im going to get in the competition.
-
Time's up!
UnderDetention: 5 votes
rekees: 2 votes
UnderDetention wins. Good job.