GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: yellow please on July 28, 2006, 02:55:11 AM
-
I think when voting you should have to give a decent reason , not just ones like
reekes... his sig pwnz has more depth smile.gif
and
srry artemis but rekees is better by far
text is nice
good colors.
and
my vote goes to aries because i really like the colour and the text , i don't really like the style that firebug used or the text but its still a really good sig
and
I voted for Fugitive because the colours pop out more smile.gif
These types of replys are just scraping the surface, they are only there because thats the first thing that came to there thoughless heads , votes should only be counnted if they show some sort of in depth veiw on the piece not just " i like it because the colors are cool "
-
The one where they voted for me, that had NOTHING wrong with it :S Look just because some people dont know everything about graphics doesnt mean shit, a signature is about what it looks like, and anybody can tell you if a signature looks good.
-
The one where they voted for me, that had NOTHING wrong with it :S Look just because some people dont know everything about graphics doesnt mean shit, a signature is about what it looks like, and anybody can tell you if a signature looks good.
I m saying that people have to give decent reasons not just , it looks cool and i liketh pretty colors :
-
I agree with fb?, many votes should not be counted. Though Biggles is in the lead. so he has to make some decisions.
-
I agree with the hole 'It looks perdy' kind of thing, but the one Arkmetis posted in mine and Firebugs battle, there was nothing wrong with it, he didnt like your style and he thought the colors went well, do you want an essay for it?!
-
do you want an essay for it?!
yes
-
do you want an essay for it?!
yes
Go to a damn graphics forum then, this is a stunting forum and you cant expect everybody to be super uber graphics know-it-alls. If you cant deal with people on the forums not all being graphics artists, dont join the graphics tourney here.
-
do you want an essay for it?!
yes
Go to a damn graphics forum then, this is a stunting forum and you cant expect everybody to be super uber graphics know-it-alls. If you cant deal with people on the forums not all being graphics artists, dont join the graphics tourney here.
Yeah but ome could at least try
-
Ok!
Firebug shut up!
I only count the posts with good explanations!
I'm still working on posting threads so the next events will be up soon and the polls will be telied and yeah
-
TBH, the quotes that fb wrote in the first post are ok, because if we will tell people to make more detailed comments... then wtf, no one will vote except 2-3 guys...
-
I don't understand why you need an explanation at all.
When you vote, is it not a vote of which piece you liked the most? I don't know shit about art, and neither does the rest of the world. If only artists like your art and the rest of the world dosen't, you're doing something wrong.
I don't need a degree in art to say which piece I liked most.
-
Personally I think your just being a bitch about it because everyone "should" be voting for you, god forbid someone have their own opinions...
-
You don't want idiot comments, open it so only people YOU think are worthy of recognising who the real winner should be actually vote and keep the television-hugging neanderthals like myself out of the artistic frame.
That would be rather unfair though.
-
The people have spoken, when you vote for the govenor or president or whatever, you put the vote in the box and thats it, you dont have to explain yourself, you like that canidate for your own reason, silly or not. Get over the fact not everybody knows everything to do with graphics, stunt forum, get used to it.
-
Ok here is what 's gonna happen!
You need 30 posts to vote so people can't just make new accounts and vote for themselves!
I want a bit of an explaination like 'The render fits well' soo for people who don't really understand gfx art don't have to do all this research to vote
Still trying to update everything
-
I agree with giving a little explanation, but nothing like 'The lightness in the render fits so well as you used double ray lighting instead of single, the render blending was nice but you couldve set the brush down in opacity blah fucking blah'
Just "I vote Serenity because his uses the render better and the color seems to fit"
-
Why? Maybe they don't even know what the a is, or maybe they don't like the colours to fit, maybe they like a sig with rainbow's coloursm, doh. They can only say "My vote goes to Fugitive", so I would probably win. Joking.
Seriously, I don't think we should count the poll votes, only the posted votes should be counted, and the 30 posts minimum rule is great. Voters should only write "[name] gmv" or just "[name]".
And the Shoutbox was great for polls because I can shout there about the poll and soon more votes will come, so I won't have to bug all my MSN list to go there and vote for somebody.
(I made it bigger because I just want the damn Shoutbox back)
-
If I'm going to vote it's probably because I'm in TMS with them. So fucking what if I support my friends.
-
Lol you're so biased...
I think the 30 post limit is a good idea, and comments show that the person has actually looked at both signatures instead of selecting a box (or circle) then pressing vote.