GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: MisguidedAngel on January 20, 2006, 09:00:40 PM
-
Again both entries were up and ready so why wait?
View Original Rules (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=10168)
So, obvious theme idea using tech for a robot styled sig. Not to hard but there is alot you can do, you could go abstract you could even use grunge and blurring. So which looks better?
InsaNe:
(http://img518.imageshack.us/img518/6940/gfxtourneyentry2finalcopy3tx.png)
Fugitive:
(http://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b8/fugitive292/Signatures/fugitive_entry2_gfxtournament.jpg)
Since people don't want me to vote right away, I will save my vote till later tommorow when I'm back from work and etc.
Cheers and gl both of ya
-
Good job both of you
InsaNe: The colors are great but maybe i a little over done , and the render look a bit too blended in , i like the effect of the cracked scanlines , goodjob.
Fugitve: The brushes really give it a hard metal effect that goes with the theme and the text effects make it look sort of industrial .
good job both of you!
my vote goes to Fugitive.
-
Hard one...
I like both sigs. The effect fugi got is awesome, but i no likey the colors.
Insane, yours is nice too. I love the scanlines <3 I prefer the text too. Colors are really nice.
My vote: Insane
-
InsaNe: The render falls into the background a bit but apart from that, good work, however it isn't special.
Fugitive: nice sig, pretty nice background, but i didn't like how did you put the render.
My vote: InsaNe
-
Xan Kriegor :grin:
-
I kinda fell for Fugi's, i love thoose kinda sig and he perfectioned it !
-
it is a hard one that, i love the colours on insanes but i dont like that render, fugi' is a really nice render but im not into the colour
my vote - fugi
-
Insane: nice render, good colors. The text is ok, but it could be placed to a different spot.
Fugitive: I like the effect you got there, but I don't like the pixel stretched bg. The text stands out too much, the font should be more techy and the color should be darker.
My vote: Insane
-
Meh no one doesn't like original sigs <_< I used 95 % smudge and 5 % texturized default brushes and no one mentions it :side:
Thanks for all who voted me btw keep em coming
-
fugitives render is kickass alltho the colors aint much.
i dont like insanes render but the colors are pretty nice
my vote : fugitive
-
InsaNe: Great work with the render and the bg. The colors are great and the diagonal lines make it looks even better. All I can complain at is the text and I miss the depth feeling.
Fugitive: A cool sig with nice colors. I don't like the text though and the border isn't very good.
My vote: InsaNe. Both sigs are on about the same level. Both needs to get some more depth and better text. InsaNe's looks better though, so he gets my vote.
-
I counted all votes and it says 4 - 4. Poll says 4 - 6 :blink:
-
Yea I like fugitive's more but grunge has been overused WAY too much.
So I vote insane.
-
Score:
InsaNe: 5
Fugitive: 4
-
I like the bright effect in InsaNe's one, dunno why :P
Both are really awesome sigs but I'm gonna vote for InsaNe, sorry Fug. :P
My vote: InsaNe
-
Since I haven't voted yet its about time,
My vote: InsaNe
Fug, your sig isn't very good tbh. I've seen your other stuff its way better then this. Your blending is off, your brushing isnt bad but its all black...which doesnt work. Your background color doesn't match with your render and your text isnt to great.
InsaNe: Like the use of different styles in this sig. Its not quite grunge, its not huge on blurring or smudging. I even like the small explosion deal you have at the top. Some parts of the sig are a lil to dark mind you but I'm sure you know where I mean.
Cheers
-
As much as i love UT i'll have to go with fudge's
-
Score:
InsaNe: 7
Fugitive: 5
-
^ Yea and voting time is up
Thanks everyone :) Fugi was challenging because he has skill too ;)