GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: MisguidedAngel on January 17, 2006, 07:47:19 PM
-
Cause I want an opponent sooner rather then later I'll set up the vote rly quickly.
View Original Rules (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?&act=ST&f=100&t=10083)
The contest was to create a signature using only basic shapes, seem easy? It rly aint.
Entries:
.priest:
(http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y275/maxr0/Signatures/167.jpg)
DMX:
(http://grottmongo.no-ip.org/~demensionx/artwork/ss.jpg)
DMX: Used pure shapes and a nice variety of colors to create a very interesting sig that looks good to the eye thanks to the color.
.priest: Slow start turned into a vector sig, I'm not a big fan of vectors and you only used black and white. It doesn't look bad but I think you coulda done alot better.
Vote: DMX
Cheers
-
.priest: if you look closely theres like shapes made out of lines...yeah thats cool
dmx: used bright colors and that sig shape is just cool and out of the ordinary
my vote goes to dmx
-
.priest - gets my vote i think it looks really sleak and cool could have used a bit more color though
DMX - i lake the way you used the shapes but the colors dont look to good to me
Vote: .priest
-
.priest - nice sig, very stylish, however i liked the first one more
DMX - i don't really like the color and i think that it's too complex
My vote: .priest
-
my vote: .priest
dmx would have won if his was more pro, looks rushed
-
my vote: .priest
dmx would have won if his was more pro, looks rushed
Agree'd and .p's has more style
-
.priest: Clean but nothing special. Not very creative, which I think is needed when making a vector sig.
DMX: More original and creative. Smooth colors which gave me a feeling of retro.
My vote: DMX
-
.priest: Clean, simplistic yet very sexy and looks really pro-ish, looks like something i'd gladly put in my signature.
DMX: Looks like some basic shapes placed randomly with some horrifying colour with a blur border and a circle with some text in the middle imo, i'd never put that in my signature.
My vote: .priest
-------
I just gotta comment this coz i feel it's a bit wrong.
I think it's a bad idea of MA to post his vote in the first post which is supposed to be neutral coz, i'd rather see a double post with his oppinion outside the neutral first post... nothing personal MA :)
-
Xtramus did the same thing
-
My vote: demx
He has basic shapes unlike .p
.p's is very cool btw
-
Xtramus did the same thing
Well i haven't checked the other topics but i think it's a good idea for everyone to keep the first post neutral in a poll don't you think?
-
lol daffy, Me thinks your the only one who cares
-
Wow, thanks alot guys :D
-
Barnz: Possibly but someone someone has to sometimes...
-
My vote: DMX
-
my vote: DMX, .priest's one has a lack of depth imo, and he did not use colors, which would look better I think. DMX has a nice variety of colors, it all fits together well. And I really like what he did w/ the border/name
-
net died when i posted so lets try again.
Brad your vote is void until you can back up your vote with some form of reason...and saying cause its better aint a valid reason.
We can just as easily not count the vote since X only counts votes that are POSTED
cheers
-
My vote DMX
he used color which is a 1 in my books. plus i love the way he got his name in there
.p
needs some color, and is your name even in it? and wtf is that thing in the corner?
good job both of you.
-
First of all thank you MA for making the poll for me :P Was at school so.. As for the voting in the first post, I don't see what's so bad about it.. But I'll stop doing it in the future.
DMX: Nice, Basic shapes, and I like your style when it comes to shapes of the sig itself: random shapes own, too bad I'm not that good at it :P But as for the sig itself: Nice colours, easy on the eye, and the text is good.
.p: A bit too random edges and shapes, it looks good but it's a bit too crowded. I do, however, like how you got the little .p in the lower right corner. Also black and white can look good, but it's gotta be more flowing IMO.
My vote: DMX.
PS: MA, love the question, nice idea :P
-
I like DMX's idea but i think its to many colors...
My vote: .p(riest)
-
This is gonna be close :o
-
You're not looking at the poll are you ... ...
-
Wrong, that's excactly what i am...
-
.priest: Nice, but I don't like it very much because it's too white.
DMX: Very nice, I like he colors.
My vote: DMX
-
[...]and is your name even in it? and wtf is that thing in the corner?
You must be fucking blind....
Thats a triple stroked circle with a ".P" in it...
-
.p - Yours was sweet dude, lots of nice shapes and looks nice overall
Dmx - I like yours a bit more, looks more original, and more colors.
My vote: DMX.
-
As it turns out daff, the polls arent what are counted. Its posted votes that are counted
(reason i beat dil 8-3 and not 14-3)
lets see the total for now *reads*
Based on posted votes that count (brads vote is void)
.priest is at 6 votes
DMX has 8
Theres still a few hours left before the 24 is up. SO VOTE NOW!
-
Thanks for helping out MA. I'll get the matches up tomorrow around 4-5 PM forum time(which is about 3-4 o' clock where I live).
-
As it turns out daff, the polls arent what are counted. Its posted votes that are counted
Aha ok, thanks for filling me in :)
-
I picked .preist just so MA would have a chance at losing, nah jk to all you guys. ;)
I don't have anything good to say about any of them but I voted for priest since DMX's colors didn't seem to blend in together. :(
-
DMX looks incredibly jumbled up, not very smooth.
.p's on the other hand looks very nice, and I think the lack of color adds to the effect.
I vote .p
Edit: :o Just realized I tied it up...
-
That you did, and with only 1 hour of voting left till the 24 hours is up...this one will be the closest match yet!
there has to be people who aint voted yet, so what you waiting for?
ONE HOUR LEFT
-
.priest , because the shapes are smooth and pretty , instead of dmx who uses agresive colors and shapes , and .p uses shades , more smooth ... the one of dmx looks like someone who puked ...
vote .p
-
.priest.
I really like how simple, but awesome the sig looks. Nice job.
DMX
It's just too colorful for me. It's like I'm in Hawaii again. The shape of the sig is cool though.
My vote goes to priest. Props.
-
Tention, cut it with a WIRE!
EDIT:
Game over,
very well done both of you and stay tuned as X will post the next round match ups. Mean while, Ill delete the old threads and update the match outline.
Cheers
DOUBLE EDIT:
Ok, it was brought to my attention that I fucked up. 2 posted votes are from members that have less then 30 posts...thus those votes, are void and do not count.
Which means there is a TIE!